Record-Low Sentiment, Record-High Stocks
Key Takeaways
- Consumer Sentiment Remains Weak: Despite historically low consumer sentiment readings and concerns about inflation, energy prices, and AI, broader economic activity has remained relatively resilient.
- Spending and Employment Continue to Show Stability: Consumer spending trends, retail sales growth, and a still-low unemployment rate suggest that economic fundamentals remain generally supportive.
- Market Performance Has Been Driven by Earnings Growth: Recent stock market gains have largely coincided with stronger corporate earnings expectations rather than higher valuations, even as interest rates have moved higher.

Consumer Sentiment Remains Near Historic Lows Despite Economic Resilience
Further illustrating the current backdrop on consumer sentiment is the most recent reading from the University of Michigan’s Index of Consumer Sentiment, which was the lowest in its 74-year history. Think about some of the events in that span of time: the Cuban Missile Crisis, the Vietnam War, Watergate, the Dotcom bust, 9/11, the Great Financial Crisis, etc. And yet, now we have the weakest consumer sentiment in 74 years? Perhaps it’s a combination of concerns around inflation, the Iran War, geopolitical changes (NATO), Ukraine/Russia, AI fears, etc. Or, perhaps sentiment is not comparable over long stretches of time.
How Inflation, AI Concerns, and Higher Energy Prices Are Influencing Consumer Behavior
Gen Z, in particular, isn’t exactly super optimistic about the future at the moment. They’re very concerned about AI and its effects on their job prospects or keeping a job if they have one. Some recent college graduation ceremonies have seen speakers booed who spoke positively of AI and its prospects. Case in point was former Google CEO Eric Schmidt’s commencement address, as he faced nearly uninterrupted boos during his May 15th speech at the University of Arizona that discussed AI’s inevitable impact on the world.
Current financial pressures and fears of the future are showing up in spending patterns. The recent quarterly earnings calls from Walmart and McDonald’s specifically cited lower-income consumers being directly impacted by higher gas prices. Walmart said that visitors to its gas stations are buying fewer than 10 gallons per visit, the lowest amount since 2022. Walmart’s CFO said that “that’s an indication of stress.” And McDonald’s CEO said that higher gas prices linked to the Iran war were disproportionately hurting low-income consumers, as the company warned of a weak start to its second quarter. The company also noted margin pressure at U.S. franchisees from inflation across food, paper and energy inputs, as well as higher operating costs that franchisees cannot fully offset through pricing.
Consumer Spending and Employment Data Continue to Show Strength
Nonetheless, aggregate consumer spending in the U.S. actually remains fairly healthy. Walmart, Target, and TJX all had strong year-over-year same store sales growth of 4.1%, 5.6%, and 6%, respectively, last quarter. Perhaps this is reflective of a shift from higher-priced retail to those more affordable options and the still very low unemployment rate of 4.3%. Weekly initial jobless claims continue to be muted and have actually trended lower, not higher, over the past twelve months, despite the fear of AI replacing workers. The dour mood from the consumer also doesn’t seem to be reflected in Wall Street economists’ outlooks for 2026 GDP – the Bloomberg consensus projects GDP to grow 2.1% this year, the same as reported for 2025.
Stock Market Gains Continue to Be Supported by Earnings Growth
The stock market may very well be capturing that underlying economic resilience. The S&P 500 continues to trudge higher; it’s up 11% year-to-date and made a new all-time high on May 29th. One year ago, the multiple on that measure of the broad market was 22.4 times expected earnings over the next 12 months and today it stands at 22.4x. This valuation metric is unchanged, despite the market having climbed 30% over the past twelve months. And that reveals that the driver of the market has been primarily earnings growth, rather than an unmoored multiple expansion.
Rising Interest Rates Have Yet to Derail Equity Market Performance
But there’s a disconnect in all of this, which is that interest rates have been moving higher. Since February 27th, the 2yr and 10yr Treasuries are up by 62 bps and 49 bps, respectively, while the S&P 500 has risen by 10.5%. This flies in the face of simplistic valuation math: higher rates reduce the present value of future earnings, so equities typically fall when rates rise. This time, equities have continued to rally despite the increase in rates. Much of that surge reflects big tech enthusiasm, but the S&P 500 Equal Weight is up 2.3% in that timeframe as well and is up 9.5% year-to-date. Further, the Equal Weight Index is trading at a reasonable 17.9x. It’s helpful that forward inflation expectations are not indicative of inflation becoming entrenched – at least at the present moment.

